Taylor vs. Serrano III: Controversial Decision? Full Fight Breakdown and Analysis

Another Chapter in a Legendary Rivalry at Madison Square Garden

The highly anticipated Taylor vs. Serrano III finally unfolded on Friday, July 11, 2025, at the iconic Madison Square Garden in New York City. This wasn’t just another fight; it was the third chapter in a rivalry that has already etched its place in boxing history. With the Undisputed Female Super Lightweight Title on the line, the stakes couldn’t have been higher. The electrifying atmosphere in the Garden was palpable as Katie Taylor and Amanda Serrano locked horns once again. The fight concluded with a majority decision victory for Taylor, a result that sparked immediate debate and discussion among fans and pundits alike. Was the decision controversial? Let’s delve into the details in this Taylor vs Serrano fight review.

• Q: Who won Taylor vs. Serrano III?
  • A: Katie Taylor beat Amanda Serrano by majority decision in their 10-round contest on Friday, July 11th, 2025, at Madison Square Garden, New York.

Fight Overview: Taylor Edges Serrano in a Close Battle for Undisputed Glory

The fight itself was a captivating display of skill, heart, and determination. Both Taylor and Serrano left everything in the ring, engaging in a back-and-forth battle that kept the audience on the edge of their seats. Neither fighter was willing to give an inch, resulting in a grueling contest that showcased the best of women’s boxing. Ultimately, Katie Taylor emerged victorious by majority decision, but the closeness of the fight left many questioning the judges’ scorecards in this Taylor Serrano results.

Round-by-Round Summary: Key Moments and Turning Points in the Trilogy

• Rounds 1-3: The fight began with a cautious feeling-out process. Serrano, known for her aggressive style, pressed forward, attempting to establish her power early. While Taylor displayed her trademark footwork and elusive movement, Serrano may have edged these rounds with higher punch output, according to early statistics. Serrano’s pressure was evident, but Taylor remained composed.
• Rounds 4-7: Taylor began to find her rhythm in the middle rounds. Utilizing her superior boxing skills and counter-punching ability, she started landing cleaner shots and controlling the pace of the fight. Her punch accuracy improved significantly during this stretch, allowing her to dictate the exchanges and frustrate Serrano’s advances. Taylor’s ring generalship became increasingly apparent as she navigated Serrano’s pressure.
• Rounds 8-10: Serrano mounted a late surge, recognizing the need to make a statement in the final rounds. She increased her aggression and punch output, attempting to overwhelm Taylor with her relentless attack. These strong closing rounds made the decision incredibly close, leaving the judges with a difficult task. Serrano’s determination was undeniable as she pushed for a knockout.
• Key Moments: Throughout the fight, several significant exchanges highlighted the intensity of the contest. No knockdowns occurred, but both fighters showed signs of fatigue as the bout wore on, testament to the grueling pace and high stakes.

Detailed Fight Analysis: Strategies, Strengths, and Weaknesses Under the Microscope

• Katie Taylor: Taylor’s strategy centered around utilizing her superior footwork, boxing skills, and counter-punching to outmaneuver Serrano. Her speed and accuracy were key assets, allowing her to land clean shots while avoiding the brunt of Serrano’s power. However, she occasionally showed susceptibility to pressure and experienced defensive lapses.
• Amanda Serrano: Serrano’s approach revolved around applying relentless pressure, unleashing powerful punches, and targeting Taylor’s body. Her strengths lie in her raw power, aggression, and unwavering attack. However, she struggled with Taylor’s movement and sometimes resorted to wild punches, which left her vulnerable to counter-attacks.
• The clash of styles was evident throughout the fight, with Taylor’s finesse contrasting Serrano’s brute force. Both fighters had moments of success, but neither could completely dominate the other. The ability to adapt as the fight progressed proved crucial, and Taylor arguably made better adjustments in the middle rounds in this Katie Taylor Amanda Serrano matchup.

The Judges’ Scorecards: A Closer Look at the Controversy

• The official judges’ scorecards read: 97-93, 95-95, 97-93 in favor of Katie Taylor.
• Q: What were the scorecards for Taylor vs. Serrano III?
  • A: The scorecards were announced as 97-93, 95-95, 97-93 in favor of Katie Taylor.
• Analyzing each judge’s scoring reveals the difficulty in separating the two fighters. Some rounds were clearly in favor of one fighter, while others were razor-close and could have gone either way. Commentary on the scoring has been divided, with some observers believing Taylor deserved the victory, while others felt Serrano did enough to win. The 95-95 scorecard reflects the tight nature of the contest and Taylor Serrano analysis.

Was Taylor Robbed? Examining the Controversy Surrounding the Taylor vs Serrano III decision

The majority decision sparked immediate controversy, with many fans and media members believing that Amanda Serrano had done enough to earn the victory. Arguments for Serrano centered on her aggression, consistent pressure, and strong closing rounds. Conversely, arguments for Taylor highlighted her cleaner shots, superior boxing skills, and effective counter-punching. Analyzing the close rounds reveals how differently they could have been scored, based on varying criteria such as aggression, ring generalship, and effective punching. The controversy underscores the subjective nature of boxing scoring and the inherent challenges in judging a fight.

Statistical Breakdown: Numbers Don’t Lie (Or Do They?) - Taylor Serrano 3 stats

• Overall Punch Stats: A detailed breakdown of the total punches landed and thrown by each fighter, along with their overall punch accuracy, reveals a close contest. While Serrano may have thrown more punches, Taylor’s accuracy could have swayed the judges in her favor.
• Jab vs. Power Punch Stats: Examining the jabs landed and thrown, as well as the power punches landed and thrown, provides insights into each fighter’s strategy. Taylor might have been more effective with her jab, while Serrano relied more on her power punches.
• Round-by-Round Stats: Significant rounds can be identified based on punch stats, highlighting those where one fighter dominated statistically. These numbers provide objective data to support observations made during the fight.
• Taylor vs Serrano 3 stats
• Q: How many rounds was the Taylor vs. Serrano III fight?
  • A: The fight was scheduled for 10 rounds.

Fighter Backgrounds: Roads to the Trilogy - Katie Taylor Amanda Serrano

• Katie Taylor: An Irish icon, Taylor’s amateur career culminated in an Olympic gold medal, solidifying her status as a boxing legend. Her professional achievements include multiple title reigns and a reputation for unwavering determination. Leading up to this trilogy, she had secured wins against top-level opposition, showcasing her resilience and skill. Recent results show she has secured wins and one controversial loss leading into this fight demonstrating she is in a competitive stage of her career. Katie Taylor stepped into the ring with a record of 24 wins, 1 loss, and 0 draws.
• Amanda Serrano: A Puerto Rican powerhouse, Serrano has captured multi-division championships and boasts an impressive KO percentage, highlighting her devastating power. Her journey to this trilogy involved overcoming various challenges and solidifying her place among the elite. In her 5 previous fights she had 4 wins and a loss. Amanda Serrano made her way to the ring with a record of 47 wins, 3 losses and 1 draw.
• Taylor was the older woman by 3 years, at 39 years old.
• Taylor had a 1-inch reach advantage.
• Katie Taylor fought out of the orthodox stance, while Amanda Serrano was a southpaw.
• Taylor was the less experienced professional fighter, having had 26 fewer fights, and made her debut in 2016, 7 years and 8 months later than Serrano, whose first professional fight was in 2009. She had fought 32 fewer professional rounds, totaling 224 compared to Serrano’s 256.
• Q: What is Katie Taylor’s record?
  • A: Katie Taylor’s record is 24 wins, 1 loss, and 0 draws.
• Q: What is Amanda Serrano’s record?
  • A: Amanda Serrano’s record is 47 wins, 3 losses, and 1 draw.

Undercard Results: A Night of Exciting Fights Before the Main Event

The Taylor vs. Serrano III undercard featured several exciting matchups that set the stage for the main event:

• Alycia Baumgardner was victorious over Jennifer Miranda.
• Ellie Scotney beat Yamileth Mercado.
• Savannah Marshall was overcome by Shadasia Green.
• Chantelle Cameron was victorious over Jessica Camara.
• Cherneka Johnson beat Shurretta Metcalf.

These fights showcased the depth and talent in women’s boxing, providing a thrilling prelude to the main event at Madison Square Garden boxing.

Post-Fight Reactions: What the Fighters and Experts Said

In post-fight interviews, Katie Taylor expressed her respect for Amanda Serrano and acknowledged the closeness of the fight. She reiterated her belief that she had done enough to win, but also praised Serrano’s performance. Amanda Serrano, while disappointed with the decision, remained gracious in defeat and hinted at a potential rematch in the future. Trainers and boxing analysts offered mixed reactions, with some supporting the decision and others arguing that Serrano deserved the victory.

Future Implications: What’s Next for Taylor and Serrano?

• Katie Taylor: As the victor and current Super Lightweight Title holder, Taylor’s future remains bright. Potential future opponents include other top contenders in the super lightweight division. Whether she will continue to defend her title or consider retirement remains to be seen.

• Amanda Serrano: Despite the loss, Serrano’s stock remains high. A rematch with Taylor is a distinct possibility, given the closeness of their previous encounters. Alternatively, she may choose to move on to other challenges and pursue titles in different weight divisions.

• Katie Taylor next fight

• Amanda Serrano next fight

Conclusion: A Trilogy to Remember in the Annals of Women’s Boxing

The Taylor vs. Serrano III fight delivered on its promise, providing a captivating and controversial conclusion to a legendary rivalry. The closeness of the contest and the disputed decision will undoubtedly fuel debate and discussion for years to come. Regardless of one’s opinion on the outcome, the Taylor-Serrano rivalry has left an indelible mark on women’s boxing, elevating the sport to new heights and inspiring future generations of female fighters. This fight will be remembered as a pivotal moment in women’s boxing history.

• Q: Where did Taylor vs. Serrano III take place?
  • A: The fight took place at Madison Square Garden, New York, United States.
• Q: What weight division was Taylor vs. Serrano III?
  • A: The fight was in the Super Lightweight division (140 pounds).
• Q: What titles were on the line in Taylor vs. Serrano III?
  • A: The Undisputed Female Super Lightweight Title was on the line.
• Q: Where can I watch Taylor vs Serrano III?
  • A: Taylor vs Serrano III was broadcast on Netflix in the United States and United Kingdom.
• Q: What other fights were on the Taylor vs Serrano III undercard?
  • A: The undercard included Alycia Baumgardner vs. Jennifer Miranda, Ellie Scotney vs. Yamileth Mercado, Savannah Marshall vs. Shadasia Green, Chantelle Cameron vs. Jessica Camara, and Cherneka Johnson vs. Shurretta Metcalf.

---

📊 Want to dive deeper into the action? Subscribe to our Boxing Data API to access full round-by-round punch stats, detailed analytics, and historical fight data.